3 Comments
User's avatar
Phil Moss's avatar

They've got this wrong like virtually all Labour policies - cretinous in the extreme.

Royc111's avatar

The net migration figures are coming down but what if we are losing young tax paying Brits and importing migrants who go straight into benefits for life bringing their many family members in too eventually. Thats a hidden underbelly we won’t be able to count… but might account for the spiralling benefits bill. What think you?!

Brian Edmunds's avatar

Hi Jamie. Another great piece.

Of course this ability to take money out of the Country is wrong. It should never be allowed. But It has been the case since Thatcher stupidly removed exchange control regulations in the late seventies early eighties.

Before then, we could not take money out of the country. We had to limit spending money abroad before then. And that control and that control change controls need to be reinstated in my view.

A particular currency of exchange, a token for which to swap work of one person for the work of others is peculiar to that country. So it must be reinstated money us for that constant exchange, it was never meant to be unused, unspent or idle. It’s meant to be exchanged!

To buy and sell with those abroad, I think it would be better if it were bought and sold in this country with sterling, so each buyer and seller must have a uk bank accounts to pay and be paid. In buying and selling our goods. To be an equal exchange. Allowing goods to flow not money!

In essence to spend the same amount as we sell. Parity! Avoiding any loss of money abroad. Let goods flow not the money out of our country. It’s all needed here.

So that’s the remedy Jamie. Reintroduce those rules that stopped such movement of money.

And as for a reduced tax take, it’s a similar thinking to that you presented to argue for higher taxes from less people.

Because at this time we are not spending enough of our money already in existence to generate enough sufficient tax revenue!

Jamie you have to understand. Tax is triggered solely by SPENDING money. So to get more tax revenue we have to spend more of our money that hitherto hasn’t been SPENT. We only SPEND a small proportion of existing money. That’s why we earn less and spend less so our tax paid us not enough! Insufficient money, insufficient flow gives insufficient tax revenue.

We know this is true, because NOT SPENDING MONEY triggers no tax whatsoever. None.

Therefore we have to conclude it’s only spending that triggers tax.

And to ensure that we generate enough spending to gain sufficient tax for all government spending then we must rotate and spend more! We are underspending and underfunding our economy by allowing too much money to be idle, unspent and unused sitting in bank accounts at home and abroad.

That’s why we have an insufficient tax take Jamie. It’s not so much tax is too high. It’s solely because not enough money is being freely spent!

Instead of enforcing spending of all money not just some. We are rotating and passing on to others indebted money! Not freely spent money because free money is being replaced by the banks who want to earn from our predicament by replacing that free money with indebted money full of repayment and interest.

Our economy should be for all. Not just the few holding vast sums with the bankers leaching off our hard work. We don’t want leveraged money we just want that money that’s idle to be freely spent back with us who supplied it!l in the first place!

And Jamie, it’s these billionaires that don’t spend! They loan it back instead so have no incentive to spend it because we have to keep repaying them and more! So they take more than money. They take even more from us by lending it back. They take interest and future profits from us.

It’s the businesses of those billionaires that paid tax not them! I can’t stress it enough Jamie. Income taxes and Nic are paid by businesses from the spending of and by us on and in those businesses. We pay the tax Jamie. It comes from our spending. It’s our money that we give up. They don’t!

If they are here they may spend some money.

But it was us who gave them our money to take abroad . And every time we spend it triggers taxes paid by the business to government. It’s not the billionaires who pay. It’s those businesses in the UK that pay towards tax. From money we spend!

So, if the business is in this country they will still earn. We will still pay them and they will still not reciprocate by spending money back with us. The money made by the billionaires paid to them by their uk business will still give them that money.

Until we all realise these facts we won’t ever see the cause let alone the answer.

Tax has a particular flow. It’s triggered by and financed by the money SPENT by us. From the money SPENT by and we got from the spending of others. It’s a flow. It’s like passing on a baton. We pass money into others by SPENDING. And tax is triggered by SPENDING. Even income taxes and Nic. But also Vat and duty. In fact all taxation is as a result of money moving by spending or by order or by need and choice. Whether it’s windfall taxes or Council Tax, insurance taxes car tax or inheritance tax. They are all triggered by spending and money moving!

So please understand this Jamie. As without it we won’t ever get the right monetary structure.