7 Comments
User's avatar
Timothy Marshall's avatar

He will probably cut and run!

Jamie Jenkins's avatar

Haha, wouldn’t put it past them! Though with these numbers, finding somewhere safe to run to might be the tricky bit. Thanks for tuning in, Timothy.

Phil Beale's avatar

Labour back benchers should realise that people sat at home with 'anxiety' will probably not even bother to go out to vote anyway. The quality of MPs has dramatically decline din recent years They now appear from academia not business Many straight from uni to an internship with another politician no life experience no business experience just pure theory. maybe we should have a minimum age for MPs and insist on a at least 3 years working in the the private sector before election

Jamie Jenkins's avatar

You hit on a massive point here, Phil. A bit of real-world commercial experience before managing the nation’s purse strings wouldn’t go amiss! Practical knowledge beats whiteboard theory every time. Appreciate the thoughtful comment.

Brian Edmunds's avatar

Jamie, your correct to highlight the government stupidity in borrowing more when the economy doesn’t have to sustain this debt.

The general view that governments can only raise government income from increasing taxation rates is stupidity itself.

Your own point that the increase in fuel prices brings in more vat is an excellent example to teach them that increasing turnover (in your case by increasing prices) acts the same way when you increase SPENDING in general!!!!!!

The point you raised was a back handed result of higher prices is resulting in higher vat take.

But as I’ve been trying to point out for months Jamie, is it also works naturally when we increase SPENDING!

And to increase SPENDING to raise vast sums of vat is just by SPENDING the money that sits idle in bank accounts at home and abroad. That could be positively affecting the take of government tax income with exponential flow of money into the economy just from SPENDING it!

You have seen the bad affect if rising prices. But you have to also see the benefit it would be by increased SPENDING could do by vastly increasing vat income!

Jamie….think of this….

If you google total sterling money in existence in uk you eventually get a figure of £19 trillion pounds. …. Now I have no idea if that is correct. But we do know coin and paper are a lot less. So the rest must be digital money and as we owe £4 trillion pounds then a total of £19 trillion sounds plausible. But if we accept that whatever the total is it surely has to be a total that should cover population and need then that figure sounds reasonable. So let’s use it for the sake of argument. My principles stay the same anyway.

If we were to SPEND all if that amount in just one rotation do spend it just the once, not millions of times a day but just once in one whole year then the vat take from that amount could well be £3,8 trillion pounds in vat alone!

As you know Jamie our government tax take now is something like £1.2 trillion from all taxation while our government spends about £1.5 trillion each year now!

So you can see Jamie, the power of spending!

When we spend we automatically clock up vat and we could be clocking up such vast sums of vat just from spending than we do now from all taxation why isn’t it our government policy to ensure money is spent??

When we spend money freely we not only pass money in to others to get paid for their work we also receive goods to that value! So we all get stuff we need now. In fair swap.

But crucially that turbo charged economy creates so much vat our government should not have to borrow anything!

Can you not see that Jamie?

Jamie Jenkins's avatar

Always appreciate your passion on velocity of money, Brian! If only we could coax every spare pound out of savings and straight into the tills overnight, the Treasury would throw a party. The trick is getting people spending without sparking runaway inflation in the process. Good food for thought as always!

Brian Edmunds's avatar

Yes Jamie I’d be first on the dance floor! Walking stick and all!

That’s the trick alright, how to get money moving?

I have s radical idea of course. Put a spend by date on money! That’ll do it for sure. Spend it or lose it to government who will spend it if you don’t.

But I think they can start by taxing it instead of wealth! Try and get money back into the flow around us. Tax unspent money. But first reinstate change controls to stop money flight. And while we’re at it swap money for a new digital in border only currency.

It’s a cliff edge moment I think. We can’t sustain this position, we’re ready to collapse me thinks.

I am very sure on one thing Jamie. Cuts will not bring about anything good. Trying to balance a loosing position is a waste of time.

Like the world being round, our people who still believe it’s flat are still in denial that the economy can work when half our money is not being spent and the other half is emptied of freely spent money but full instead of indebted and leveraged money! Yes that top heavy seesaw is a great position to be stuck in!

That unnecessary position is unsustainable.

The only way an economy works is by all its money rotating. Not some, not part not nearly enough no! It has to be over a sufficient amount that makes it work for all. It had to reach its optimum of flow. Speed and exchange.

It’s not a question of if it will ever work? It will never work. It has never worked and it will never work. It only works one way. Exchanging tokens for goods. Receiving tokens for production.

Unless it’s exchanged, in full then the concept of tokens to exchange fails its job!

What’s the point in having money for exchanging if we don’t have it exchanging?

Or it we’re not for exchanging then Why don’t we just get given money every month? Then we can keep everything we don’t use!?

Yes, just keep printing the stuff. It’s alright, we’ll have hyper inflation but at least it keeps us with money to not spend.

As for inflation? Well I think normal inflation is growth! It’s the real cost. That money flow must keep up with. But doesent! Inflation is no problem in my mind as long as the flow of that increased amount flows back again to keep pace with it.

If money goes more in one direction it has to return to allow it to go back again at that higher amount. It’s then when prices increase we need government to pump new money in.

If world costs go up of course we need new currency to keep pace with it. After all it’s not tied to a gold standard. We don’t have to underfund ourselves. It’s our currency after all.

If populations rise it costs rise or needs must of course rise so we can increase the total pot of money with reason.

Inflation is only dangerous to the borrowing costs of government and our ability to buy.

It’s allowing part to rise without putting up the amount of tokens to use! They are after all only tokens Jamie.

If you’ve got a village hall raffle that has 100 people it’s a waste of time having only ten tickets! You’re excluding 90 People entry to the prizes. It’s the same principle.

The complete machinery has to be catered for. It’s no good enough having 70 million people but money tokens for just 20 million whilst we have 50 million of tokens doing nothing! That’s my point.

How is that best practice of best management!??